The Art of Packaging

Can Plastic Jar and Bottle Lids Be Recycled?

Close-up of a blue recycling bin with a white recycling symbol

Most plastic caps are recyclable, and in most U.S. curbside programs the best way to get them recycled is to screw them back onto the empty bottle. That wasn't always the advice, and it doesn't apply to every cap, liner or pump. Here's what caps are made of, what current guidance says, which parts usually can't be recycled, and what brands can do to make their packaging easier to recycle.

  • #5Polypropylene (PP), the most common cap plastic
  • #2HDPE, used for some caps and many bottles
  • Caps onCurrent guidance from the Association of Plastic Recyclers

What caps and lids are made of

Resin identification code 5 recycling symbol for polypropylene (PP)
Most plastic caps are #5 polypropylene.

Whether a cap can be recycled starts with its material. Look for a resin code molded into the top or inside of the cap, though small caps often don't have room for one.

  • Polypropylene (PP, #5): the large majority of screw caps, flip-tops, disc-tops and jar lids. PP is stiff, holds a thread well and survives repeated opening, which is why it dominates closures. See our guide to polypropylene.
  • High-density polyethylene (HDPE, #2): used for some caps, especially on milk jugs and larger containers, and for some tamper-evident closures.
  • Phenolic (thermoset): hard, glossy black caps often used on glass bottles for oils, solvents and lab chemicals. Phenolic is a thermoset, so it can't be melted and remolded. It is not recyclable in curbside programs.
  • Metal: steel or aluminum lids, common on glass food jars and some cosmetic jars. Metal is recyclable, but how a small lid is handled varies by program.

PP and HDPE are both thermoplastics with established recycling markets, so a plain PP or HDPE cap is recyclable in principle. Whether it actually gets recycled depends on whether it makes it through the sorting facility, which is where the "caps on or off" question comes in.

Current guidance: put the cap back on

For years, consumers were told to remove caps before recycling. That advice dated from a time when recyclers couldn't handle caps mixed in with bottles, and when caps were made from a different plastic than the bottle.

That has changed. The Association of Plastic Recyclers (APR), the U.S. trade group for plastic recyclers, now recommends leaving caps on empty plastic bottles. At the reclaimer, bottles are ground into flakes and washed, then the flakes go through a water bath. PET bottle flake sinks, while PP and HDPE cap flake floats, so the two materials separate cleanly and both can be sold.

The How2Recycle label, the standardized recycling label used by many U.S. brands, reflects the same approach with its "Empty & Replace Cap" instruction: empty the container, then screw the cap back on before it goes in the bin.

Always check local rulesRecycling is run locally, and programs accept different materials. Some still ask residents to remove caps or to leave out certain plastics. Your city or hauler's website is the final word for what goes in your bin.

Why loose caps get lost

The main problem with caps isn't the plastic, it's the size. At a materials recovery facility (MRF), mixed recycling moves across screens and conveyors that separate items by size and shape. Small items fall through the gaps along with broken glass and other debris.

Facilities describe this differently, and there's no single national cutoff, but a common rule of thumb is that anything smaller than about two to three inches is likely to be lost. A loose bottle cap is well under that. It usually ends up in the landfill-bound residue or contaminates the glass stream.

A cap screwed onto its bottle travels with the bottle, gets baled and shipped to a plastics reclaimer, and is separated there. That's why "caps on" captures more material than "caps off."

Liners, pumps, sprayers and other exceptions

"Caps on" applies to plain plastic caps on plastic bottles and jars. Other closures are more complicated.

Cap liners

Many caps contain a liner: foam, pressure-sensitive, or a heat seal (induction) liner with a foil layer. Liners left in the cap usually travel along with it. A peeled-off induction seal is a thin multi-material film and generally goes in the trash.

Pumps and sprayers

Most lotion pumps and trigger sprayers combine several plastics with a metal spring, and sometimes a metal ball or glass bead. They can't be separated at a MRF. Unless your program or the product label says otherwise, remove them and put them in the trash, then recycle the bottle.

Caps on glass jars

APR's "caps on" guidance is about plastic bottles. Plastic or metal lids on glass jars are usually removed, because they interfere with glass processing. Many programs accept metal lids separately; check yours.

Phenolic and mixed-material caps

Phenolic caps can't be recycled. Caps with metal shells, decorative overcaps or glued-on parts are also hard to recycle and usually belong in the trash.

Jar lids raise one more question. Large jar lids, such as an 89 mm cap, may be big enough to make it through sorting on their own, but many programs still prefer the lid be put back on the empty, rinsed jar. Follow your local guidance.

What brands can do

If recyclability matters to your customers, the choices you make at the packaging stage have the biggest effect.

  • Choose common, compatible plastics. A PP or HDPE cap on a PET, HDPE or PP container is the best-understood combination for recyclers. Avoid phenolic caps unless your product needs them for chemical resistance.
  • Keep it simple. A one-material closure is easier to recycle than one with a metal shell, glued parts or mixed plastics. If you need a pump or sprayer, consider whether a dispensing cap such as a disc-top or snap-top would do the job.
  • Use only the liner you need. Liners protect the product and prevent leaks, so don't drop one you need. But if a liner-free cap seals well with your product, it's one less material. Our Liner Guide explains the options.
  • Label clearly. The How2Recycle program lets member brands put standardized instructions such as "Empty & Replace Cap" on their labels, based on an assessment of the package. Even without it, a short line on your label telling customers what to do with the cap helps.
  • Avoid overstating recyclability. "Recyclable" claims are regulated, and acceptance varies by location. Keep claims specific and accurate.

Common questions

Should I take the cap off a plastic bottle before recycling it?

In most U.S. programs, no. Empty the bottle and put the cap back on. Caps left loose are too small to be sorted and usually end up as waste. Check your local program, since a few still ask for caps off.

What number are plastic bottle caps?

Most are #5 polypropylene. Some are #2 HDPE. Small caps often have no code molded in.

Can I recycle a pump or spray top?

Usually not. Most pumps and sprayers contain a metal spring and several different plastics. Remove them and put them in the trash unless the product label or your program says they're accepted. Better yet, reuse them on a refill bottle.

Are black plastic caps recyclable?

It depends on the material. A black PP cap is the same plastic as any other PP cap. A hard black phenolic cap is a thermoset and isn't recyclable. Some sorting equipment also has trouble detecting black plastic, which matters more for large black containers than for caps attached to a bottle.

What about metal lids on glass jars?

Remove them from the jar. Many programs accept metal lids, sometimes with special instructions such as placing them inside a can. Check your local rules.

Choose closures with recycling in mind

PP caps, dispensing caps and liners in a wide range of neck finishes, with single units available so you can test before you buy in bulk.

Citadel Packaging customer support

Real people. Real service.

Have a packaging question? Talk to a specialist.

We can help you choose the right container, closure and liner for your product, and send free samples ($10 shipping) so you can test before you buy.

Recently viewed